This page contains practice problems that require you to know both the washerdisc method and the cylindershell method.
Recommended Books on Amazon (affiliate links)  

Join Amazon Student  FREE TwoDay Shipping for College Students 
For these problems, we assume that you have worked lots of problems on the washerdisc and cylindershell pages. So you are comfortable working problems that tell you which technique to use. For these problems, we may not tell you which technique to use or you may be asked to use both. Sometimes you will need to set up both integrals and work one or both. Keep in mind that your answer should be the same regardless of which technique you use.
We do not go into a lot of explanation of the basics in these problems. If you don't understand something, go back to the page and section with the technique that you are struggling with and go through those problems again. They have a lot of explanation that will help you with these problems.
These problems are meant to help you hone your skills before your exam. Probably, your exam will not tell which technique to use, so you may have to decide, or you will be asked to use both techniques on the same problem.
Notes 

1. There are several groups of problems that have the same area rotated about different axes. These are good to work consecutively and to compare your results, so that you can get a feel for how the different axes affect solutions.
2. Many of these problems have limits of integration that are the same for both methods. This is unusual and does not always happen. In these problems, the reason they are equal is due to the choice of the enclosed areas. So do not expect it to happen for every problem.
3. As you work through these problems, compare the two techniques and start to notice patterns. For example, since the rectangles of the two methods are perpendicular, you will always integrate one with respect to \(x\) and the other with respect to \(y\).
Practice
Unless otherwise instructed, use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to solve these problems. Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Make sure to use correct notation and give your answers in exact, simplified form.
Group 1
For these four problems, the area in the plane is the same, \( y=x^2, x=0, y=1 \). Each problem rotates this area about a different axis.
area: \( y=x^2, x=0, y=1 \)  axis of rotation: \(y=2\)  method: both 
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=x^2, x=0, y=1 \) revolved about \(y=2\). Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Hint 

built with GeoGebra 

Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=x^2, x=0, y=1 \) revolved about \(y=2\). Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Final Answer 

\( V = 52\pi/15 \)
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=x^2, x=0, y=1 \) revolved about \(y=2\). Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Hint 

built with GeoGebra 

Solution 

1. Set up the plots with labels  See the hint for the plots and enclosed area. Although we could have put everything on one plot, we decided to do two separate plots for clarity. Check with your instructor to see what they require. It may help to use colour to separate each technique.
2. Choose The Integrals  The two integrals we need are \(V=\pi\int_a^b{R^2r^2~dx}\) for the washerdisc method and \(V=2\pi\int_c^d{ph~dy}\) for the cylindershell method.
3. Determine p, h, r and R  By now, you should be able to know how to determine the distances, since you worked the practice problems on the washerdisc and cylindershell pages. So we just present the answers here.
washerdisc method  \(r=2+x^2\)  \(R=3\) 
cylindershell method  \(p=2+y\)  \(h=\sqrt{y}\) 
4. Set Up the Integrals
washerdisc method  \(\displaystyle{ V = \pi\int_0^1{ 3^2  (2+x^2)^2 ~ dx } }\) 
cylindershell method  \(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi\int_0^1{ (2+y)\sqrt{y}~dy }}\) 
Note: The limits of integration for these two integrals are equal. However, that will not usually occur.
5. Evaluate the Integrals
washerdisc method 

\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi\int_0^1{ 3^2  (2+x^2)^2 ~ dx } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi\int_0^1{ 944x^2x^4 ~ dx } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi \left[ 5x  \frac{4x^3}{3}  \frac{x^5}{5} \right]_0^1 }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi \left[ 5  \frac{4}{3}  \frac{1}{5} \right] = \frac{52\pi}{15} }\) 
cylindershell method
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi\int_0^1{ (2+y)\sqrt{y}~dy }}\)
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi\int_0^1{ 2y^{1/2}+y^{3/2} ~dy }}\)
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi \left[ \frac{2y^{3/2}}{3/2} + \frac{y^{5/2}}{5/2} \right]_0^1 }\)
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi \left[ \frac{4}{3} + \frac{2}{5} \right] = \frac{52\pi}{15} }\)
Final Answer 

\( V = 52\pi/15 \)
close solution

Log in to rate this practice problem and to see it's current rating. 

area: \( y=x^2, x=0, y=1 \)  axis of rotation: \(x=1\)  method: both 
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=x^2, x=0, y=1 \) revolved about \(x=1\). Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Hint 

built with GeoGebra 

Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=x^2, x=0, y=1 \) revolved about \(x=1\). Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Final Answer 

\( V = 11\pi/6 \)
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=x^2, x=0, y=1 \) revolved about \(x=1\). Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Hint 

built with GeoGebra 

Solution 

1. Set up the plots with labels  See the hint for the plots and enclosed area. Although we could have put everything on one plot, we decided to do two separate plots for clarity. Check with your instructor to see what they require. It may help to use colour to separate each technique.
2. Choose The Integrals  The two integrals we need are \(V=\pi\int_c^d{R^2r^2~dy}\) for the washerdisc method and \(V=2\pi\int_a^b{ph~dx}\) for the cylindershell method.
3. Determine p, h, r and R  By now, you should be able to know how to determine the distances, since you worked the practice problems on the washerdisc and cylindershell pages. So we just present the answers here.
washerdisc method  \(r=1\)  \(R=1+\sqrt{y}\) 
cylindershell method  \(p=1+x\)  \(h=1x^2\) 
4. Set Up the Integrals
washerdisc method  \(\displaystyle{ V = \pi\int_0^1{ (1+\sqrt{y})^2  1^2 ~ dy } }\) 
cylindershell method  \(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi\int_0^1{ (1+x)(1x^2)~dx } }\) 
Note: The limits of integration for these two integrals are the same. However, that will not usually occur.
5. Evaluate the Integrals
washerdisc method 

\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi\int_0^1{ (1+\sqrt{y})^2  1^2 ~ dy } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi\int_0^1{ 1+2\sqrt{y}+y1 ~ dy } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi \left[ \frac{2y^{3/2}}{3/2} + \frac{y^2}{2} \right]_0^1 }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi \left[ \frac{4}{3} + \frac{1}{2} \right] = \frac{11\pi}{6} }\) 
cylindershell method 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi\int_0^1{ (1+x)(1x^2)~dx } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi\int_0^1{ 1x^2+xx^3 ~dx } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi \left[ x  \frac{x^3}{3} + \frac{x^2}{2}  \frac{x^4}{4} \right]_0^1 }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi \left[ 1  \frac{1}{3} + \frac{1}{2}  \frac{1}{4} \right] = \frac{11\pi}{6} }\) 
Final Answer 

\( V = 11\pi/6 \)
close solution

Log in to rate this practice problem and to see it's current rating. 

area: \( y=x^2, x=0, y=1 \)  axis of rotation: \(y=6\)  method: both 
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=x^2, x=0, y=1 \) revolved about \(y=6\). Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Hint 

built with GeoGebra 

Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=x^2, x=0, y=1 \) revolved about \(y=6\). Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Final Answer 

\( V = 36\pi/5 \)
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=x^2, x=0, y=1 \) revolved about \(y=6\). Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Hint 

built with GeoGebra 

Solution 

1. Set up the plots with labels  See the hint for the plots and enclosed area. Although we could have put everything on one plot, we decided to do two separate plots for clarity. Check with your instructor to see what they require. It may help to use colour to separate each technique.
2. Choose The Integrals  The two integrals we need are \(V=\pi\int_a^b{R^2r^2~dx}\) for the washerdisc method and \(V=2\pi\int_c^d{ph~dy}\) for the cylindershell method.
3. Determine p, h, r and R  By now, you should be able to know how to determine the distances, since you worked the practice problems on the washerdisc and cylindershell pages. So we just present the answers here.
washerdisc method  \(r=5\)  \(R=6x^2\) 
cylindershell method  \(p=6y\)  \(h=\sqrt{y}\) 
4. Set Up the Integrals
washerdisc method  \(\displaystyle{ V = \pi\int_0^1{ (6x^2)^25^2 ~ dx } }\) 
cylindershell method  \(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi\int_0^1{ (6y)\sqrt{y} ~dy } }\) 
Note: The limits of integration for these two integrals are the same. However, that will not usually occur.
5. Evaluate the Integrals
washerdisc method 

\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi\int_0^1{ (6x^2)^25^2 ~ dx } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi\int_0^1{ 1112x^2+x^4 ~ dx } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi \left[ 11x\frac{12x^3}{3}+\frac{x^5}{5} \right]_0^1 }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi \left[ 114+\frac{1}{5} \right] = \frac{36\pi}{5} }\) 
cylindershell method 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi\int_0^1{ (6y)\sqrt{y} ~dy } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi\int_0^1{ 6\sqrt{y}y^{3/2} ~dy } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi \left[ \frac{6y^{3/2}}{3/2}  \frac{y^{5/2}}{5/2} \right]_0^1 }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi \left[ 4  \frac{2}{5} \right] = \frac{36\pi}{5} }\) 
Final Answer 

\( V = 36\pi/5 \)
close solution

Log in to rate this practice problem and to see it's current rating. 

area: \( y=x^2, x=0, y=1 \)  axis of rotation: \(x=2\)  method: both 
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=x^2, x=0, y=1 \) revolved about \(x=2\). Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Hint 

built with GeoGebra 

Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=x^2, x=0, y=1 \) revolved about \(x=2\). Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Final Answer 

\( V = 13\pi/6 \)
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=x^2, x=0, y=1 \) revolved about \(x=2\). Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Hint 

built with GeoGebra 

Solution 

1. Set up the plots with labels  See the hint for the plots and enclosed area. Although we could have put everything on one plot, we decided to do two separate plots for clarity. Check with your instructor to see what they require. It may help to use colour to separate each technique.
2. Choose The Integrals  The two integrals we need are \(V=\pi\int_c^d{R^2r^2~dy}\) for the washerdisc method and \(V=2\pi\int_a^b{ph~dx}\) for the cylindershell method.
3. Determine p, h, r and R  By now, you should be able to know how to determine the distances, since you worked the practice problems on the washerdisc and cylindershell pages. So we just present the answers here.
washerdisc method  \(r=2\sqrt{y}\)  \(R=2\) 
cylindershell method  \(p=2x\)  \(h=1x^2\) 
4. Set Up the Integrals
washerdisc method  \(\displaystyle{ V = \pi\int_0^1{ 2^2  (2\sqrt{y})^2 ~ dy } }\) 
cylindershell method  \(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi\int_0^1{ (2x)(1x^2) ~dx } }\) 
Note: The limits of integration for these two integrals are the same. However, that will not usually occur.
5. Evaluate the Integrals
washerdisc method 

\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi\int_0^1{ 2^2  (2\sqrt{y})^2 ~ dy } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi\int_0^1{ 4  4 + 4\sqrt{y}  y ~ dy } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi \left[ \frac{4y^{3/2}}{3/2}  \frac{y^2}{2} \right]_0^1 }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi \left[ \frac{8}{3}  \frac{1}{2} \right] = \frac{13\pi}{6} }\) 
cylindershell method 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi\int_0^1{ (2x)(1x^2) ~dx } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi\int_0^1{ 22x^2x+x^3 ~dx } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi \left[ 2x\frac{2x^3}{3}\frac{x^2}{2}+\frac{x^4}{4} \right]_0^1 }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi \left[ 2  \frac{2}{3}\frac{1}{2}+\frac{1}{4} \right] = \frac{13\pi}{6} }\) 
Final Answer 

\( V = 13\pi/6 \)
close solution

Log in to rate this practice problem and to see it's current rating. 

Group 2
For these four problems, the area in the plane is the same, \( y=\sqrt{x}, y = x/2 \). Each problem rotates this area about a different axis.
For these problems only, set up the integrals but do not evaluate them.
area: \( y=\sqrt{x}, y=x/2 \)  axis of rotation: xaxis  method: both 
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=\sqrt{x}, y=x/2 \) revolved about the xaxis. Set up the integrals only. Do not evaluate them.
Solution 

video by blackpenredpen 

close solution

Log in to rate this practice problem and to see it's current rating. 

area: \( y=\sqrt{x}, y=x/2 \)  axis of rotation: yaxis  method: both 
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=\sqrt{x}, y=x/2 \) revolved about the yaxis. Set up the integrals only. Do not evaluate them.
Solution 

video by blackpenredpen 

close solution

Log in to rate this practice problem and to see it's current rating. 

area: \( y=\sqrt{x}, y=x/2 \)  axis of rotation: \(x=5\)  method: both 
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=\sqrt{x}, y=x/2 \) revolved about \(x=5\). Set up the integrals only. Do not evaluate them.
Solution 

video by blackpenredpen 

close solution

Log in to rate this practice problem and to see it's current rating. 

area: \( y=\sqrt{x}, y=x/2 \)  axis of rotation: \(y=3\)  method: both 
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=\sqrt{x}, y=x/2 \) revolved about \(y=3\). Set up the integrals only. Do not evaluate them.
Solution 

video by blackpenredpen 

close solution

Log in to rate this practice problem and to see it's current rating. 

These remaining problems are different areas.
area: \( y=1/(x+1), y=1x/3 \)  axis of rotation: xaxis  method: both 
Problem Statement 

Unless otherwise instructed, use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=1/(x+1), y=1x/3 \) revolved about the xaxis. Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Hint 

built with GeoGebra 

Problem Statement 

Unless otherwise instructed, use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=1/(x+1), y=1x/3 \) revolved about the xaxis. Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Final Answer 

\( V = 8\pi/27 \)
Problem Statement 

Unless otherwise instructed, use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=1/(x+1), y=1x/3 \) revolved about the xaxis. Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Hint 

built with GeoGebra 

Solution 

1. Set up the plots with labels  See the hint for the plots and enclosed area. Although we could have put everything on one plot, we decided to do two separate plots for clarity. Check with your instructor to see what they require. It may help to use colour to separate each technique.
2. Choose The Integrals  The two integrals we need are \(V=\pi\int_a^b{R^2r^2~dx}\) for the washerdisc method and \(V=2\pi\int_c^d{ph~dy}\) for the cylindershell method.
3. Determine p, h, r and R  By now, you should be able to determine the distances, since you worked the practice problems on the washerdisc and cylindershell pages. So we just present the answers here.
washerdisc method  \(r=1/(x+1) \)  \(R=1x/3\) 
cylindershell method  \(p=y\)  \(h=(33y)(1/y1)=43y1/y\) 
4. Set Up the Integrals
washerdisc method  \(\displaystyle{ V = \pi\int_0^2{ \left(1\frac{x}{3} \right)^2  \left( \frac{1}{x+1} \right)^2 ~dx } }\) 
cylindershell method  \(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi\int_{1/3}^1{ y(43y1/y) ~dy } }\) 
5. Evaluate the Integrals
washerdisc method 

\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi\int_0^2{ \left(1\frac{x}{3} \right)^2  \left( \frac{1}{x+1} \right)^2 ~dx } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi\int_0^2{ 1\frac{2x}{3}+\frac{x^2}{9}  \frac{1}{(x+1)^2} ~dx } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi \left[ x\frac{2x^2}{6}+\frac{x^3}{27} \right]_0^2  \pi \int_0^2{ \frac{dx}{(x+1)^2} } }\) 
In the last line, the remaining integral is easily evaluated using integration by substitution where \(u=x+1\). It evaluates to \(2/3\). 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi \left[ 2\frac{4}{3}+\frac{8}{27}\frac{2}{3} \right] = \frac{8\pi}{27} }\) 
cylindershell method 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi\int_{1/3}^1{ y(43y1/y) ~dy } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi \int_{1/3}^1{ 4y3y^21 ~dy } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi \left[ \frac{4y^2}{2}\frac{3y^3}{3} y \right]_{1/3}^1 }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi \left[ 211 \right] 2\pi \left[ \frac{2}{9}  \frac{1}{27}  \frac{1}{3} \right] = \frac{8\pi}{27} }\) 
Final Answer 

\( V = 8\pi/27 \)
close solution

Log in to rate this practice problem and to see it's current rating. 

area: \( y=x, y^3=x, x \geq 0 \)  axis of rotation: xaxis  method: both 
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=x, y^3=x, x \geq 0 \) revolved about the xaxis. Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Hint 

built with GeoGebra 

Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=x, y^3=x, x \geq 0 \) revolved about the xaxis. Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Final Answer 

\( V = 4\pi/15 \)
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=x, y^3=x, x \geq 0 \) revolved about the xaxis. Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Hint 

built with GeoGebra 

Solution 

1. Set up the plots with labels  See the hint for the plots and enclosed area. Although we could have put everything on one plot, we decided to do two separate plots for clarity. Check with your instructor to see what they require. It may help to use colour to separate each technique.
2. Choose The Integrals  The two integrals we need are \(V=\pi\int_a^b{R^2r^2~dx}\) for the washerdisc method and \(V=2\pi\int_c^d{ph~dy}\) for the cylindershell method.
3. Determine p, h, r and R  By now, you should be able to know how to determine the distances, since you worked the practice problems on the washerdisc and cylindershell pages. So we just present the answers here.
washerdisc method  \(r=x \)  \(R=x^{1/3}\) 
cylindershell method  \(p=y\)  \(h=yy^3\) 
4. Set Up the Integrals
washerdisc method  \(\displaystyle{ V = \pi\int_0^1{ x^{2/3}x^2 ~dx } }\) 
cylindershell method  \(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi\int_0^1{ y(yy^3) ~dy } }\) 
Note: The limits of integration for these two integrals are the same. However, that will not usually occur.
5. Evaluate the Integrals
washerdisc method 

\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi\int_0^1{ x^{2/3}x^2 ~dx } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi \left[ \frac{x^{5/3}}{5/3} \frac{x^3}{3} \right]_0^1 }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi \left[ \frac{3}{5} \frac{1}{3} \right] = \frac{4\pi}{15} }\) 
cylindershell method 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi\int_0^1{ y(yy^3) ~dy } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi\int_0^1{ y^2y^4 ~dy } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi \left[ \frac{y^3}{3}  \frac{y^5}{5} \right]_0^1 }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = 2\pi \left[ \frac{1}{3}  \frac{1}{5} \right] = \frac{4\pi}{15} }\) 
Final Answer 

\( V = 4\pi/15 \)
close solution

Log in to rate this practice problem and to see it's current rating. 

area: \( y=\sqrt{\ln(x^2)}, y=\sqrt{\ln x}, y=1 \)  axis of rotation: xaxis  method: both 
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=\sqrt{\ln(x^2)}, y=\sqrt{\ln x}, y=1 \) revolved about the xaxis. Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Hint 

built with GeoGebra 

This solution requires the evaluation of the integral \( \int{\ln(x)~dx} \), which requires integration by parts. Since you may not have had integration by parts yet, here is the evaluate of that integral.
\( \int{\ln(x)~dx} = x \ln(x)  x + C \)
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=\sqrt{\ln(x^2)}, y=\sqrt{\ln x}, y=1 \) revolved about the xaxis. Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Final Answer 

\( V = \pi[1+e2e^{1/2}] \)
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=\sqrt{\ln(x^2)}, y=\sqrt{\ln x}, y=1 \) revolved about the xaxis. Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Hint 

built with GeoGebra 

This solution requires the evaluation of the integral \( \int{\ln(x)~dx} \), which requires integration by parts. Since you may not have had integration by parts yet, here is the evaluate of that integral.
\( \int{\ln(x)~dx} = x \ln(x)  x + C \)
Solution 

1. Set up the plots with labels  See the hint for the plots and enclosed area. Although we could have put everything on one plot, we decided to do two separate plots for clarity. Check with your instructor to see what they require. It may help to use colour to separate each technique.
2. Choose The Integrals  The two integrals we need are \(V=\pi\int_a^b{R^2r^2~dx}\) for the washerdisc method and \(V=2\pi\int_c^d{ph~dy}\) for the cylindershell method.
3. Determine p, h, r and R and set up integrals  From the plots, we can tell that cylindershell method will be easier since only one integral is required. But we were asked to set up both, so let's start with the easy one. This is probably what you would do on an exam.
cylindershell method 
Our integral is \(V=2\pi\int_c^d{ph~dy}\). Since this is in terms of y, we will probably need our functions solved for x. So let's go ahead and do that.
\( y=\sqrt{\ln(x^2)} \to y^2 = \ln(x^2)\)
This is a valid operation since x and y are both positive.
\( y^2 = \ln(x^2) \to e^{y^2} = e^{\ln(x^2)} = x^2 \to x = e^{y^2/2}\)
Similarly for the second equation, we have
\(y=\sqrt{\ln x} \to y^2 = \ln x \to x=e^{y^2}\)
So for our two curves, we have
upper curve  \(y=\sqrt{\ln(x^2)}\)  \(x=e^{y^2/2}\) 
lower curve  \(y=\sqrt{\ln(x)}\)  \(x=e^{y^2}\) 
Of course, these equations do not hold for all x and y, just in the first quadrant, which our area is in. So we are okay.
So, we determined that the equation we need is \(V=2\pi\int_c^d{ph~dy}\). The equation for p is pretty easy, it is just y. The equation for h is also pretty easy if you remember how to get the length of a line between two curves in the y direction (from the area between two curves page). It is just the equation of the line on the right minus the equation of the line on the left. In this case, we have \(h=e^{y^2}  e^{y^2/2}\).
These give the resulting integral of \(V=2\pi\int_0^1{y(e^{y^2}  e^{y^2/2})~dy}\)
washerdisc method 
We decided to do this method second, since finding the volume is more difficult in that we need two integrals. At the point \(x=e^{1/2}\), the top end of the rectangle jumps from the curve \(y=\sqrt{\ln(x^2)}\) to \(y=1\). So we are going to have one integral on the interval \([1,e^{1/2}]\) and a second integral on the interval \([e^{1/2},e]\). Let's work left to right, so we we will start with the interval \([1,e^{1/2}]\). The distance r is from the axis of rotation, the xaxis, to the lower plot. So this distance is \(r=\sqrt{\ln x}\). The distance R is also pretty easy. It goes from the xaxis to the upper plot, which is \(R=\sqrt{\ln(x^2)}\). These results give our first integral as \(V_1=\pi \int_1^{e^{1/2}}{ \ln(x^2)\ln(x) ~dx}\).
For the second interval/integral, we have the distance r the same as the previous interval and for the distance R, we have \(R=1\) no matter where the example rectangle is. So our second integral is \(V_2=\pi\int_{e^{1/2}}^e{1\ln(x)~dx}\)
Our total volume we have \(V=V_1+V_2 = \pi \int_1^{e^{1/2}}{ \ln(x^2)\ln(x) ~dx} + \) \( \pi\int_{e^{1/2}}^e{1\ln(x)~dx}\).
At this point, we may be tempted to try to combine these integrals somehow but it is better to leave them separate for now, for two reasons. First, it may not be possible to combine them and, in most cases, we can't. Secondly, trying to do so introduces the possibility of making a mistake. So we will leave them as they are.
4. Evaluate the Integrals
Let's look at the washerdisc method integrals first. Notice that in both integrals we have \(\int{\ln(x)~dx}\). This integral requires the technique integration by parts, which you have probably not had yet. So, we gave you the answer in the hint. If you want to see how to do this integral, see the integration by parts page.
washerdisc method 

\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi \int_1^{e^{1/2}}{ \ln(x^2)\ln(x) ~dx} + }\) \(\displaystyle{ \pi\int_{e^{1/2}}^e{1\ln(x)~dx} }\) 
Since \(\ln(x^2) = 2\ln 2\), the integrand of the first integral is \(2\ln(x)\ln(x)=\ln(x)\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi \int_1^{e^{1/2}}{ \ln(x) ~dx} + \pi\int_{e^{1/2}}^e{1\ln(x)~dx} }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi \left[ x\ln x  x \right]_1^{e^{1/2}} + \pi\left[ x(x\ln x x) \right]_{e^{1/2}}^e }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi[ 1+e2e^{1/2}]}\) 
cylindershell method 
\(\displaystyle{ V=2\pi\int_0^1{y(e^{y^2}  e^{y^2/2})~dy} }\) 
Use integration by substitution. 
\(u=y^2 \to du=2y~dy \) 
Converting the limits of integration from y's to u's, we have 
\(y=1 \to u=1\) and \(y=0 \to u=0\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V=2\pi\int_0^1{ e^u  e^{u/2} (du/2) } }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V= \pi\left[ e^u  2e^{u/2} \right]_0^1 }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V = \pi[ 1+e2e^{1/2}]}\) 
Final Answer 

\( V = \pi[1+e2e^{1/2}] \)
close solution

Log in to rate this practice problem and to see it's current rating. 

area: \( y=xx^4, y=0 \)  axis of rotation: xaxis  method: both 
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=xx^4, y=0 \) revolved about the xaxis. Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Hint 

built with GeoGebra 

Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=xx^4, y=0 \) revolved about the xaxis. Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Final Answer 

\( V = \pi/9 \)
Problem Statement 

Use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to calculate the volume of revolution produced by the area \( y=xx^4, y=0 \) revolved about the xaxis. Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Give your answer in exact form.
Hint 

built with GeoGebra 

Solution 

1. Set up the plot with labels  See the hint for the plot and enclosed area. There is no way to easily solve the equation for x, so we cannot do the cylindershell method.
2. Choose The Integral  The integral we need is \(V=\pi\int_a^b{R^2r^2~dx}\) for the washerdisc method.
3. Determine r and R and set up integral  Since the axis of rotation runs right along one edge of the area, \(r=0\). The distance R is just \(y=xx^4 \to R=xx^4\). So our integral is \(V=\pi\int_0^1{ (xx^4)^2 ~dx}\)
4. Evaluate the Integral
washerdisc method 

\(\displaystyle{ V=\pi\int_0^1{ (xx^4)^2 ~dx} }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V=\pi\int_0^1{ x^22x^5+x^8 ~dx} }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V=\pi \left[ \frac{x^3}{3}\frac{2x^6}{6} +\frac{x^9}{9} \right]_0^1 }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ V=\pi \left[ \frac{1}{3}\frac{1}{3} +\frac{1}{9} \right] = \frac{\pi}{9} }\) 
Final Answer 

\( V = \pi/9 \)
close solution

Log in to rate this practice problem and to see it's current rating. 

You CAN Ace Calculus
external links you may find helpful 

Larson Calculus (Google books) Volume  Disk, Washer Methods and Shell, Cylinder Methods pgs 458477 
The Unit Circle
The Unit Circle [wikipedia]
Basic Trig Identities
Set 1  basic identities  

\(\displaystyle{ \tan(t) = \frac{\sin(t)}{\cos(t)} }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ \cot(t) = \frac{\cos(t)}{\sin(t)} }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ \sec(t) = \frac{1}{\cos(t)} }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ \csc(t) = \frac{1}{\sin(t)} }\) 
Set 2  squared identities  

\( \sin^2t + \cos^2t = 1\) 
\( 1 + \tan^2t = \sec^2t\) 
\( 1 + \cot^2t = \csc^2t\) 
Set 3  doubleangle formulas  

\( \sin(2t) = 2\sin(t)\cos(t)\) 
\(\displaystyle{ \cos(2t) = \cos^2(t)  \sin^2(t) }\) 
Set 4  halfangle formulas  

\(\displaystyle{ \sin^2(t) = \frac{1\cos(2t)}{2} }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ \cos^2(t) = \frac{1+\cos(2t)}{2} }\) 
Trig Derivatives
\(\displaystyle{ \frac{d[\sin(t)]}{dt} = \cos(t) }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ \frac{d[\cos(t)]}{dt} = \sin(t) }\)  
\(\displaystyle{ \frac{d[\tan(t)]}{dt} = \sec^2(t) }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ \frac{d[\cot(t)]}{dt} = \csc^2(t) }\)  
\(\displaystyle{ \frac{d[\sec(t)]}{dt} = \sec(t)\tan(t) }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ \frac{d[\csc(t)]}{dt} = \csc(t)\cot(t) }\) 
Inverse Trig Derivatives
\(\displaystyle{ \frac{d[\arcsin(t)]}{dt} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{1t^2}} }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ \frac{d[\arccos(t)]}{dt} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{1t^2}} }\)  
\(\displaystyle{ \frac{d[\arctan(t)]}{dt} = \frac{1}{1+t^2} }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ \frac{d[\arccot(t)]}{dt} = \frac{1}{1+t^2} }\)  
\(\displaystyle{ \frac{d[\arcsec(t)]}{dt} = \frac{1}{\abs{t}\sqrt{t^2 1}} }\) 
\(\displaystyle{ \frac{d[\arccsc(t)]}{dt} = \frac{1}{\abs{t}\sqrt{t^2 1}} }\) 
Trig Integrals
\(\int{\sin(x)~dx} = \cos(x)+C\) 
\(\int{\cos(x)~dx} = \sin(x)+C\)  
\(\int{\tan(x)~dx} = \ln\abs{\cos(x)}+C\) 
\(\int{\cot(x)~dx} = \ln\abs{\sin(x)}+C\)  
\(\int{\sec(x)~dx} = \) \( \ln\abs{\sec(x)+\tan(x)}+C\) 
\(\int{\csc(x)~dx} = \) \( \ln\abs{\csc(x)+\cot(x)}+C\) 
To bookmark this page and practice problems, log in to your account or set up a free account.
Do you have a practice problem number but do not know on which page it is found? If so, enter the number below and click 'page' to go to the page on which it is found or click 'practice' to be taken to the practice problem.
 
The 17Calculus and 17Precalculus iOS and Android apps are no longer available for download. If you are still using a previously downloaded app, your app will be available until the end of 2020, after which the information may no longer be available. However, do not despair. All the information (and more) is now available on 17calculus.com for free. 
Practice Instructions
Unless otherwise instructed, use both the washerdisc and cylindershell methods to solve these problems. Evaluate both integrals, if possible, to confirm that your answers are the same. Make sure to use correct notation and give your answers in exact, simplified form.