## 17Calculus Infinite Series - Practice Problem 2435

Infinite Series Practice Problem 2435

$$\displaystyle{\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}{\frac{\sin(n)}{n^3+n+1}}}$$

Determine the convergence or divergence of the series.
If the series converges,
- determine the value the series converges to, if possible; and
- determine if the series converges absolutely or conditionally.

Choosing Which Tests To Try

Rejecting the Obvious

1. This is not an alternating series, telescoping series or one of the special series. Although there are some positive and negative terms, if you write out the first few terms, you can tell that they are not alternating or telescoping.
2. Also, a quick calculation tells us that the limit of $$a_n$$ is zero. So the divergence test will not help us.
3. The form of $$a_n$$ contains $$\sin(n)$$ in the numerator and a polynomial in the denominator. This combination is a problem to integrate. So we set aside the use of the integral test for the moment.
4. Applying the root test will give us a complicated denominator and $$\sqrt[n]{\sin(n)}$$ in the numerator. So we will put that aside for now and come back to it only if nothing else works.

What We Are Left With

5. Now we are left with the ratio test and the two comparison tests, the limit comparison test and the direct comparison test. There is nothing else that jumps out to tell us that one of them will work best. So we will try them in order as they appear in the infinite series table.

Applying The Tests

### Ratio Test

$$\displaystyle{ a_n = \frac{\sin(n)}{n^3+n+1} }$$ and $$\displaystyle{ a_{n+1} = \frac{\sin(n+1)}{(n+1)^3+(n+1)+1} }$$

$$\begin{array}{rcl} \displaystyle{\lim_{n \to \infty}{ \abs{\frac{a_{n+1}}{a_n}} }} & = & \displaystyle{\lim_{n \to \infty}{ \abs{\frac{\sin(n+1)}{(n+1)^3+(n+1)+1} \frac{n^3+n+1}{\sin(n)}} } } \\ & = & \displaystyle{\lim_{n \to \infty}{ \abs{\frac{\sin(n+1)}{\sin(n)} \frac{n^3+n+1}{(n+1)^3+(n+1)+1}} } } \end{array}$$

Unfortunately, we have a term $$\sin(n+1)/\sin(n)$$ whose limit cannot be evaluated. To see this, we do a little bit of trig.

$$\sin(n+1) = \sin(n)\cos(1)+\cos(n)\sin(1)$$

$$\displaystyle{ \frac{\sin(n)\cos(1)+\cos(n)\sin(1)}{\sin(n)} = \cos(1) + \sin(1)\frac{\cos(n)}{\sin(n)} = \cos(1)+ \sin(1)\cot(n) }$$

Looking at the graph of $$y=\cot(x)$$, you can see that it oscillates. So the limit does not exist. This means the ratio test is inconclusive.

Conclusion
Since the limit $$\displaystyle{ \lim_{n \to \infty}{ \abs{\frac{a_{n+1}}{a_n}} } }$$ does not exist, the ratio test is inconclusive.

### Limit Comparison Test

$$\displaystyle{ a_n = \frac{\abs{\sin(n)}}{n^3+n+1} }$$
For large $$n$$ the $$n^3$$ term dominates in the denominator and $$\abs{\sin(n)} \leq 1$$. So let's compare this series with the test series $$\sum{t_n}$$ where $$\displaystyle{t_n = \frac{1}{n^3} }$$.
Since $$t_n$$ is a p-series with $$p=3$$, the test series converges. The limit comparison test requires us to set up the limit $$\displaystyle{ \lim_{n \to \infty}{\frac{a_n}{t_n}} }$$.
$$\begin{array}{rcl} \displaystyle{\lim_{n \to \infty}{\frac{a_n}{t_n}}} & = & \displaystyle{\lim_{n \to \infty}{ \frac{\abs{\sin(n)}}{n^3+n+1} \frac{n^3}{1} }} \ & = & \displaystyle{\lim_{n \to \infty}{ \frac{\abs{\sin(n)}}{1+1/n^2+1/n^3} }} \end{array}$$
This last limit does not exist since the limit of the numerator does not exist. So the limit comparison test cannot be used to prove convergence or divergence.

### Direct Comparison Test

$$\displaystyle{ a_n = \frac{\sin(n)}{n^3+n+1} }$$

Before we start with the direct comparison test, we have to look carefully at the requirements. Notice that in both inequalities, we require that $$a_n > 0$$. However, for this series, the sine term introduces some negative terms. So we can't just directly use the direct comparison test. This is an important detail. If we don't handle this detail, we can't use the direct comparison test.

Fortunately, we have a theorem to help us. The absolute convergence theorem tells us that if $$\sum{\abs{a_n}}$$ converges, then $$\sum{a_n}$$ also converges. In this case,
$$\displaystyle{ \abs{a_n} = \abs{\frac{\sin(n)}{n^3+n+1}} = \frac{\abs{\sin(n)}}{\abs{n^3+n+1}} }$$
Since $$n > 0$$ the denominator is always positive so we just need to replace $$\sin(n)$$ with $$\abs{\sin(n)}$$. So, in this problem, we will work toward convergence. If we get the result that the series diverges, then we can't use the absolute convergence theorem and the result is inconclusive.

For large $$n$$ the $$n^3$$ term dominates. In the numerator, $$\abs{\sin(n)}$$ is always less than or equal to one, let's compare this series with the test series $$\sum{t_n}$$ where $$\displaystyle{t_n = \frac{1}{n^3} }$$.

Since $$t_n$$ is a p-series with $$p=3>1$$, the test series converges. So the direct comparison test requires us to set up the inequality as $$a_n \leq t_n$$.

$$\begin{array}{rcl} a_n & \leq & t_n \\ \displaystyle{\frac{\abs{\sin(n)}}{n^3+n+1}} & \leq & \displaystyle{\frac{1}{n^3}} \\ \abs{\sin(n)} & \leq & \displaystyle{\frac{n^3+n+1}{n^3}} \\ \abs{\sin(n)} & \leq & \displaystyle{1 + \frac{1}{n^2} + \frac{1}{n^3}} \end{array}$$

The last inequality is always true since $$\abs{\sin(n)}\leq 1$$ and the right side is always greater than one. So the series converges.

Conclusion
The series $$\sum{a_n}$$ converges by the direct comparison test and converges absolutely by the absolute convergence theorem.
There is a similar practice problem on the direct comparison test page.

test/series works? notes no limit is zero, so test is inconclusive no not a p-series no not a geometric series no not an alternating series no not a telescoping series no inconclusive no unable to evaluate limit yes no not integrable no too complicated

The series converges absolutely.

Notes

1. To be able to use the direct comparison test, we had to use the absolute convergence theorem.
2. This is one of the few series problems that can be easily solved with only one test. Most series convergence/divergence can be proved using more than one test.

Really UNDERSTAND Calculus

 all infinite series topics L'Hopitals Rule

### Search Practice Problems

Do you have a practice problem number but do not know on which page it is found? If so, enter the number below and click 'page' to go to the page on which it is found or click 'practice' to be taken to the practice problem.

When using the material on this site, check with your instructor to see what they require. Their requirements come first, so make sure your notation and work follow their specifications.

DISCLAIMER - 17Calculus owners and contributors are not responsible for how the material, videos, practice problems, exams, links or anything on this site are used or how they affect the grades or projects of any individual or organization. We have worked, to the best of our ability, to ensure accurate and correct information on each page and solutions to practice problems and exams. However, we do not guarantee 100% accuracy. It is each individual's responsibility to verify correctness and to determine what different instructors and organizations expect. How each person chooses to use the material on this site is up to that person as well as the responsibility for how it impacts grades, projects and understanding of calculus, math or any other subject. In short, use this site wisely by questioning and verifying everything. If you see something that is incorrect, contact us right away so that we can correct it.